WASHINGTON — A recent Treasury analysis highlights the repealing the credit union tax-exemption as one of the key methods of increasing tax breaks for corporations, which CUNA stated is entirely unacceptable.
Pointing to letters obtained by the group from President George W. Bush that said the president believed credit unions should maintain their tax-exemption, CUNA President/CEO Dan Mica objected to the Treasury Conference on Business Taxation and Global Competitiveness Background Paper proposal. He wrote, "To achieve the goal of reduced corporate income taxes, the paper focuses on repealing various business tax breaks, listing the exemption of credit union income among the preferences. Such a listing wholly contradicts the 2004 letter to CUNA from President Bush in which he stated, "I support strongly the tax-exempt status of credit unions, and will continue to highlight the important contributions that credit unions make to our financial system."
He continued, "While silent on the substantial benefits of credit unions to consumers, the paper lauds Subchapter S Corporations, characterizing many of them as "small." Yet an April Government Accountability Office study showed that Subchapter S banks, which are often quite large (two have over $10 billion in assets), cost the federal government $726 million in lost revenues in 2006." The Government Accountability Office has reviewed other bank tax preferences as well, which came to a total of $1.3 to $1.9 billion by CUNA's figuring.
Recommended For You
Mica also emphasized the public policy purpose behind the credit union tax exemption. "In the case of credit unions, study after study has shown that not only do they pay higher rates on savings and charge lower rates and fees but the presence of credit unions in the marketplace encourages other institutions to offer more favorable rates, providing enormous economic benefit to consumers throughout the country," her wrote. "The tax exemption for credit unions bestowed and reaffirmed by Congress recognizes the significance of credit unions–the only consumer owned financial institutions in this country.
"Under this Administration, the Treasury has consistently recognized the benefits of credit unions and stated its support for the credit union tax exemption; we urge that position be continued."
A copy of the letter was forwarded to House Ways & Means Chairman
Charlie Rangel (D-N.Y.) and Financial Services Committee Chairman Barney Frank (D-Mass.).
© 2025 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.