There has been a lot of controversy lately concerning credit unions' involvement in subprime lending, especially as it concerns indirect lending. Even the credit union federal regulator has addressed the issue. My personal belief is that participation in subprime lending can be a very positive and inclusive product for a credit union's membership, if it is done correctly.

Yes, credit unions will need to charge a higher interest rate to cover the risk for a borrower with a lower FICO score. But the alternative to offering a higher interest rate loan is a decline on the application. This sends an even stronger negative message to the member. In my experience I have not seen a great deal of financial service consumers leave because of a higher rate as long as a lower rate is offered when their credit improves. However, I have seen many consumers leave their financial institution because their application was turned down.

Let me share a personal story.

Recommended For You

Recently my family sold my childhood homestead in a small town in Utah. Because of my career in financing automobiles, it became my responsibility to liquidate my father's 1973 Toyota FJ-40 Land Cruiser that had been stored in our barn for 20 years. When I asked my mother for the title to the vehicle so I could sell it, I was intrigued with the document she gave me. The document was an installment sales contract that my father had signed when he purchased the vehicle. I was astonished when I reviewed the contract and realized that the APR was disclosed as 13.50%. The prime rate at the time was around 6 % (see federal prime rate history). I knew my father was a good credit risk and had paid his obligations in a timely manner, and I wondered why he paid such a high interest rate. As I thought about what some of the reasons may be for the higher rate, my mind reflected on the use of FICO scores. During the 1980s, when I worked at Zions First National Bank, FICO scores were not available. My experience prior to that time was that many financial institutions charged much higher interest rates for noncommercial consumer borrowers. I believe this was the case with my father on his 1973 Toyota Land Cruiser at the 13.50% rate. As consumers became more aware of FICO scores they began to demand better rates from their lending institutions. Lenders also were generous with rates to their best borrowers. Without a higher interest rate cushion that many financial institutions had previously enjoyed to mediate risk on higher risk consumers, many financial institutions began shying away from consumers with lower FICO scores and derogatory credit histories. This type of environment left many credit challenged borrowers without financing options. Thus, my father's situation. It takes more than just good underwriting to manage a successful subprime lending portfolio. A large part of the success of a subprime portfolio is within the consumer service and collections area. Much of the success in subprime lending comes from changing poor paying habits to on-time and regular payment habits. Collection habits were established early by contacting the borrowers. As a lender, the underwriting department rehearses payment dates and expectations before closing the sale of any contract. Sub-prime borrowers need constant and vigorous collection activity to be successful. In many cases, customer service agents gain a personal rapport with the borrower as he, or she perform early and frequent contacts to collect payments. This is not a kinder, gentler consumer service call. Consumer service agents must be firm and assertive in his or her collection efforts.

The lender also needs decisive action when managing these accounts, even if that includes repossession of collateral and remarketing early if there is no potential for repayment of the loan. In my experience, I have not seen many successful subprime collection efforts combined together with a prime collection department. They are just too different. Enhanced computer systems are needed with modern sophistication that are geared towards this specific sub-prime consumer and an early collection efforts. In my opinion the subprime lending market is here to stay for financial institutions, and if managed correctly, credit unions' auto loan services can benefit from it. Concentrating only on consumers with the highest FICO scores can be a very narrow market with very little yield and ignores a very large underserved market. Economies have cycles, businesses have cycles, and so does a consumer's credit. My advice is this: Stand by a lower FICO score consumer even though he or she may be charged a higher interest rate for a time, help them improve their credit scores, then offer them a lower rate when their credit justifies, and you will have a member for life.

NOT FOR REPRINT

© Touchpoint Markets, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more inforrmation visit Asset & Logo Licensing.