There are many words used to describe credit unions, but none quite as descriptive as "cheap and sheep," a behind-the-scenes favorite whispered by credit union vendors behind closed doors. CU vendors expect customers and potential customers to drive a hard bargain. It is normal procedure for those on the buying end to both push for the best deal and consult reliable references. But according to many vendors, credit unions all too often carry it to extremes, and to put it mildly, frequently look down their noses at those attempting to make a sale to a CU. As one well-known national data processor put it, "credit unions expect a fair price for their product. Rightly so. But so do we. If credit unions gave the store away with unrealistic savings and loan rates, they would soon be out of business. Same holds true for our firm. Yet, typically, they try and nickel and dime us to death, often comparing us to a product with far fewer enhancements." It's a known fact among credit union vendors that it's tough making a solid bottom line selling to credit unions, especially for those vendors who deal with credit unions exclusively or almost so. One example of many: credit unions have a reputation for not being able to make decisions. Or taking forever to do so. Or getting too many people involved in the process. Often times it's because some CEOs feel the need to take everything to their boards even though they only meet monthly thereby delaying any decisive action automatically. In some cases, boards demand to make the final decision, but not until vendors dot every "I" and cross every "T" to their satisfaction, not management's. Vendors dread time-wasting board presentations. Sometimes they must make several of them even for the purchase of small ticket items, a decision that should be made at the staff level. They have little choice but to make them if they want the sale. And make them. And then make them again. Vendors don't lay the blame for the snail-like decision making process entirely at the feet of boards. In some cases the credit union's management staff was over its head in trying to communicate exactly what the credit union needs, especially with high tech vendors. Or they decided to throw their weight around making unreasonable demands on vendors hungry for new business. Every year new vendors, some of them with an established national reputation, discover the credit union market and decide to test the waters. They do all the right things to get noticed. They buy trade publication advertising. They conduct direct mail campaigns. They take a booth in the expo program at the major state and national credit union conventions. They make individual cross country sales calls. Some even seek trade group endorsements. Even when they have good products, offered at a fair price, the credit union way of making buying decisions, and the cheap and sheep factor, eventually wears them down. Within a year or two, they throw in the towel. If vendors could be perfectly honest with their customers and potential customers, they might come up with the ten commandments of good credit union/vendor relationships. Like these: 1.)
Treat vendors with respect. They are professionals and experts in their fields. They are not peddlers just trying to make a buck. 2.)
Look on vendors as partners and another player on the management team. They want the credit union to succeed. The better the CU does, the better they will do. 3.)
Recommended For You
Everything, from houses and cars, to groceries and restaurant meals, come in a range of prices. So do products and services offered to credit unions. It may be an old clich but you get what you pay for. 4.)
Be honest regarding who can make a decision. Then make it. Not every purchase is a life-threatening decision. 5.)
CU staff needs to have the expertise to understand the product or service being offered if they are to communicate effectively with a vendor and make a sale that is win/win. 6.)
Nothing will be gained by credit unions bad mouthing a former vendor. There usually are two sides to every story. With vendor mergers and consolidations so prevalent today, a credit union could very easily end up with the same vendor returning under a new name. 7.)
Credit unions looking to buy need to do their homework. Reading CU trade publication advertisements is the best place to start. 8.)
Stop by the expo booths of vendors that interest you. Listen to their sales pitch. This information will prove to be far more valuable to the credit union than a shopping bag of trinkets. 9.)
Be completely open and honest with vendors. They can't meet your real needs if they don't know what they are. Above all, don't lead them on if the credit union has no interest in their product. 10.) Finally, don't change the rules midway through the buying courtship. If there is a price maximum, get it on the table up front. Other deal breakers should be disclosed early on too. Much of the success of the credit union industry can be traced back to individuals who saw a credit union need that wasn't being met and went out and developed a product or service to meet it. Or to solve a problem. Or to make a credit union more member friendly. Or to enable a credit union to be more efficient and more competitive. Without such vendors, credit unions would not be nearly as successful as they have become. Here's one more thing vendors won't tell you: It's time that credit unions look at vendors as problem solvers for the credit union rather than as hucksters in plaid suits trying to trick credit unions into buying something they don't need or want over a nice dinner paid for by the vendor. Comments? Call 1-800-345-9936, Ext. 15, or Fax 561-683-8514, or E-mail [email protected].
© 2025 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.