In the evolving landscape of innovation and fraud, credit unions face the unique challenge of navigating how to protect themselves and their members while staying true to the community-first values that define their institutions. As artificial intelligence begins to influence both how fraud is committed and how it can be prevented, the environment is shifting, and the stakes are rising.
According to Experian’s 2025 U.S. Identity & Fraud Report, nearly 60% of businesses reported an increase in fraud losses over the past year. Meanwhile, U.S. consumers lost an estimated $12.5 billion to fraud in 2024, a 25% jump from the previous year, according to the FTC. These numbers reflect a growing reality that fraud is becoming more complex and AI is accelerating its reach.
To stay ahead of increasingly sophisticated fraud, credit unions must adopt the right prevention strategies and leverage AI-driven tools to strengthen their defenses, protect their members and maintain trust and transparency.
A Growing Threat Requires a Multilayered Approach
Many businesses, including credit unions, are more aware and worried about the rising threat of fraud, with almost all businesses (90%) reporting they are concerned. Identity theft, transactional payment fraud and account takeover were the top fraud events experienced by companies last year.
As criminals continue to leverage AI to find new, innovative ways to commit fraud, companies risk falling behind as they grapple with the best ways to respond. Data shows that 72% of business leaders anticipate AI-generated fraud and deepfakes to be a major concern by 2026, but they may not know the best path forward to address it.
To keep pace with dynamic, AI-driven threats, credit unions should review their current fraud strategies and incorporate new techniques such as behavioral analytics that can identify a variety of new threats in real time. By adopting a multilayered fraud prevention strategy and integrating advanced technologies, credit unions can better mitigate risks and fight AI with AI all while delivering secure, seamless member experiences.
Member Trust Is Foundational
Building trust must remain a strategic priority – continuously earned and reinforced. Findings show that 57% of consumers are still concerned about doing things online and their top fears include identity theft, stolen credit card information, online privacy, fake/phishing emails, messages or phone scams, and false information.
As consumers become more aware and concerned about fraud, they increasingly expect the businesses they interact with to identify them accurately and keep them safe throughout their digital experiences. In fact, over 80% of consumers expect companies to act on security or privacy concerns, and half want stronger online safeguards. And while 85% of businesses believe their fraud controls align with consumer expectations, less than half of people are highly trusting of companies to address their concerns online.
To meet these expectations, credit unions have an opportunity to lead with innovation. Many businesses are still relying on traditional verification methods like passwords and PINs, while more secure methods that people say make them feel safest, like biometrics and behavioral analytics, remain underused.
By leveraging AI-powered identity verification and fraud detection tools, credit unions can offer members a more secure and seamless experience that balances protection with convenience while meeting their expectations. These technologies can help credit unions detect threats in real time, adapt to evolving fraud methods, and authenticate members with greater accuracy, all while preserving the trust that is central to their mission.
Building Confidence in AI Through Transparency and Education
Credit unions not only need to contend with how to embrace AI to fight fraud, but they must also explore ways to help people feel more comfortable with the technology. Data shows that some businesses are more open to embracing AI for fraud prevention, but less than one in four consumers report interacting with AI-driven tools and only 18% completely trust them.
Credit unions can help close this gap by emphasizing transparency, clearly communicating how fraud prevention tools work and sharing how member data is protected. This includes investing in fraud education across onboarding, digital channels and member communications, and including visible security measures to ensure people feel informed and empowered.
As fraud continues to evolve, the strategies used to prevent it must too. For credit unions, this presents a meaningful opportunity to strengthen defenses and deepen member relationships through innovation, transparency and trust. By embracing AI-powered tools and aligning fraud prevention with consumer expectations, credit unions can stay ahead of emerging threats while continuing to deliver the secure, personalized experiences their members expect.
© Arc, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to TMSalesOperations@arc-network.com. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.