Employee engagement is dropping. Gallup research indicates that in 2024, engagement dropped to its lowest level in the past 10 years. While AIHR ranks fair compensation outside of the top 10 drivers of engagement, compensation is highly connected to other drivers like leadership quality, recognition and rewards, and effective communication.

When credit union leaders aren’t confident in the organization’s pay philosophy, they struggle to communicate clearly about pay. And when employees don't have transparent communication about how their pay is calculated and why, they can feel unappreciated for their work.
The journey to boost engagement with compensation isn’t about giving everyone a pay raise – it’s about transforming pay conversations with the building blocks of transparency, clear communication and trust.

Navigating and Enhancing Pay Transparency

Compensation and employee salaries used to be a taboo topic. Credit unions are sometimes concerned about potential negative feedback from employees if pay ranges are shared more broadly. Pay transparency legislation has pushed organizations to mature their compensation programs. According to Payscale’s Compensation Best Practices Report, 56% of organizations are publishing pay ranges in job postings.
The influx of pay information online has emboldened employees to ask more questions about pay. Employees are more invested in how and why pay decisions are made because of quick access to compensation data.

Openly discussing compensation practices builds trust throughout the organization and is the foundation for confident pay conversations that engage employees. Credit unions need to reevaluate compensation practices and clearly communicate them across the organization to foster an engaging workplace.

These three things can help credit unions be transparent about pay:

  • Create and communicate your pay philosophy. Be clear about pay practices and how they connect with employee pay. Your pay philosophy should ensure consistency and help employees understand how compensation decisions are made.
  • Ensure fairness, clarity and alignment with company values and goals. Employees should feel confident that their pay is calculated equitably and objectively. Regular pay audits and benchmarking can help maintain fairness and reinforce transparency.
  • Providing clear career paths and pay ranges. Transparent career paths help employees understand how their compensation can grow with their career.

Engaging workplaces are built on transparency. That transparency helps leaders have better conversations with employees.

Strategic Refinement Builds Leader Confidence

Part of the barrier to infusing confidence in pay conversations is that leaders don’t fully understand the intricacies of pay. It’s difficult to communicate if they lack understanding. HR can reinforce confidence in compensation calculations by providing visibility into job pricing and where the data comes.

Bank leaders want to know that HR has done their due diligence when it comes to pay. They want confidence that salary data is pulled from multiple reliable and trusted sources and that the company compares its salaries to other similar organizations.

Knowing this information helps them have confident conversations about pay. But they need training to communicate about pay clearly and confidently and have more meaningful compensation conversations with employees.

HR can empower leaders to have confident conversations about pay with:

  • Talking points about pay practices;
  • Practice compensation conversations; and
  • Data documents showing the hows and whys of pay on the individual level.

Equipping leaders with the right tools and knowledge helps create a culture of trust and clarity around pay. When leaders feel confident in pay discussions, employees feel they are valued team members and can see how their work impacts the credit union.

Engage Employees With Your Pay Strategy

Employee engagement is the emotional connection between employees and their work, team and organization. When we think about the link between pay and engagement, we want compensation to reinforce that emotional connection.

By aligning the credit union’s compensation strategy with company initiatives, leaders can communicate to employees how salaries are determined, strengthen the tie between performance and pay, and communicate pay decisions and career growth opportunities effectively.
Employees want to understand how their pay is connected to their performance and is aligned with the organization’s goals. When credit union leaders can confidently talk about pay, they create an environment where employees feel valued for their contributions and are motivated to perform at high levels.

With clear career paths and salary potential, employees feel their companies are invested in their growth and future, leading to increased engagement.

To effectively use compensation as an engagement tool, organizations should:

  • Have data-backed pay conversations. Show employees “the math” behind their pay.
  • Connect pay to performance. Have ongoing conversations about performance and what employees can work toward on an individual, team and company level.
  • Discuss career advancement. Help employees see the big picture and how development and learning opportunities can lead to promotions and pay increases.

After making these changes, compare engagement survey responses about pay. You’ll likely see an increase in employees feeling their pay is fair for the work they do.

Building a Culture of Confidence

Compensation confidence starts with transparency. When credit union leaders can clearly explain how pay is determined and how employee contributions impact compensation, they build trust – and in turn – engagement.

Transforming pay conversations helps employees feel connected to their work. When credit unions commit to transparency, equip leaders to have confident pay conversations, and connect the dots for employees between their work and their pay, they create an engaging workplace.

Jennifer Klapak

Jennifer Klapak is Director of HR and Learning and Development for the $4.7 billion, St. Paul, Minn.-based Affinity Plus Federal Credit Union.

NOT FOR REPRINT

© Arc, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to TMSalesOperations@arc-network.com. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.