Quantcast
Go Search
 
CEOs Need ‘Merging Competency,’ Finds CUNA Report 
4/19/2010 

Credit union CEOs have developed a newfound “merger competency” that is fast becoming part of their skill set, according to a new white paper report issued Monday by the CUNA Councils.

The 19-page report, written on behalf of all six CUNA Councils, found that mergers sometimes flounder because of too much focus on the financials and operations whereas the “critical element” for CU managers is “knowing the importance of tradition and culture.”

“While integrating two cultures, capable leaders know the importance of symbols and signals in communicating with employees about change,” said the paper entitled “Developing a Merger Competency.”

The report said the merger landscape is shifting in ways both subtle and dramatic noting that more than a third of all CUs operating in 2008, for example, had participated in at least one merger between 1979 and 2008.

“Attitudes are also evolving; mergers are no longer considered the last resort for a failing institution,” the report concluded. “In some cases they are part of a thoughtful strategy for healthy credit unions.”

Ellis Waller, manager of CUNA membership in Madison, Wis. noted that the merger issue has gained higher prominence in recent months.

 The last time a report was developed by all six councils was in May 2009 for a report on courtesy pay. The six councils include: Chief Financial Officers, Human Resources, Training, Lending, Marketing and Business Development, Operations-Sales-Service and Technology.

Readers Comments

Name:
Email (will not be published):
Subject:
Comment:

    • 4/20/2010 11:57:02 AM
    • henry wirz
    • Merger Competency
    • I would agree that culture is important. A credit union must have shared culture of doing the right thing for the right reason and a culture that is focused on specific outcomes for members, staff and the communities in which the credit union operates. But I disagree that financial and operational matters are less important. They are at least equally important. When we assess another credit union as a potential merger partner we look at a series of qualifications beginning with the financial aspect. If a merger does not work financially then it just can not be done. The next most important aspect is whether or not the potential merger partner has a viable franchise which will help support the on-going financial success of the credit union. As the article mentions, in many cases the merger partner is only merging because of finanical problems. In those cases the credit union has often ruined the franchise with sub par member service for a long time. The CAMEL rating system needs to add a S for service quality. Most mergers occur only after the regulators force the issue. Regulators should see poor service as leading indicator of future financial problems and should either force management to improve service or seek a merger with a management team that can improve service.
    • 4/20/2010 12:49:24 PM
    • Blair Evan Ball
    • CEOs Need ‘Merging Competency,’ Finds CUNA Report
    • I agree with your assessment where the CU's focus too much on the financial and operations. I've seen mergers go smoothly because the cultures matched, and then I've seen where the culture is entirely different which causes more challenges, wastes energy and the good talent usually go elsewhere.
    • 4/21/2010 5:37:15 PM
    • Nancy Monson
    • Merger Challenges
    • The difficulty with integrating cultures during a merger stems from a distorted view of the organization's "real culture" at the top. Research on culture shows that in almost every case, the senior leaders' perception of the culture is much more idealized than the rest of the organization. When trying to integrate cultures, it is imperative to have an accurate picture of the cultures to minimize difficulties and speed the integration process.

Most Viewed Articles


Related Articles

Related Categories