Given that no losses have been incurred, the range of expected outcomes between NCUA numbers and WesCorp numbers is mind boggling. Modeling the expected performance is based solely on the underlying assumptions. To make these unilateral decisions without disclosing the assumption that drove these numbers is incomprehensible. If the NCUA truly believes these numbers, then what does that say about all the mortgage loans and home equity loans on all credit union and bank balance sheets? The Obama administration has clearly taken steps to stimulate the economy; these measures need to be given an opportunity to work.
The decision by the NCUA was based on analysis performed by PIMCO, and the results and assumptions have not been shared with the credit unions that are directly affected by this. The lack of transparency and the actions taken March 20 clearly indicate to me that the wheels were in motion prior to the receipt of the PIMCO report. I find it incredibly ironic that when the public-private asset purchase plan was reported on at the beginning of this week, PIMCO was one of the first firms willing to do its part to help remove toxic assets from the balance sheets of financial institutions. I don't know what the contractual arrangements are between PIMCO and the NCUA, but the appearance of a possible conflict cannot be ignored.
We have seen a significant increase in our member deposits since the end of 2008. We have taken the advice of the NCUA and deposited or invested those funds in our corporate credit union in order to improve its liquidity. Given the decrease to net worth as a result of these actions and the increase in our balance sheet, pressure is being placed on our net worth ratio, and we are aggressively cutting our share rates to discourage additional deposits. The recent news of the conservatorship did not cause a reaction by our membership since the names of the corporates do not resonate with the average consumer. However, when all the credit unions file their first-quarter 5300 reports and the losses are published, I fear our members as well as the members of all credit unions across this country will inundate the credit unions with phone calls. Bankrate and BauerFinancial update their assessments on each financial institution on a quarterly basis. The actions by the NCUA will reflect on our ratings and may erode member confidence. There are 90 million members of credit unions across the country and to have to explain the reason why this happened will be very challenging.
Chief Financial Officer
Meriwest Credit Union
San Jose, Calif.
Just Say No to Government Aid
It is vital credit unions not accept government aid like the banks. It would put us in the same position as the banks. Much of the public considers the banks stealing from the taxpayers. I appreciate Credit Union Times providing a different view than credit unions like The Golden 1.
If credit unions accept government aid during these difficult times, the public will no longer support us. It will destroy our movement. If we act like a bank, we will be taxed like a bank. Everyone needs to take care what this recklessness will do to our industry.
Current Member and Former IT Analyst
Farmers Insurance Group FCU